Irish Chukka Setter Irish Traveler men's Setter a0wqdZ

FANDOM


This page describes one of Memory Alpha's policies and guidelines.

Please read through the policy below to familiarize yourself with our common practices and rules.
If you have any questions, suggestions, or complaints, please post them on the talk page.

Star Trek is fiction and, for various reasons, the "facts" of this fictional universe are often contradictory. As this is an encyclopedia of those facts, it is quite appropriate to note those discrepancies in Memory Alpha articles. There is an anomaly, however, that while difficult to define, is certainly undesirable: the Nitpick.

Criteria Edit

To decide whether a note on the contradiction of facts should be included, four properties must be evaluated: evidence, substance, neutrality, and placement.

  • How well established are the facts that contradict?
  • Is the note substantive? How big of a contradiction is it really? How important is it to the character, to the story, to the production, to Star Trek as a whole? Almost all information on Memory Alpha is trivial. Setting a threshold of "too trivial for inclusion" is difficult.
  • Does it make judgments about the contradiction? Is it critical of the writers or production staff?
  • Where should the note be placed? Most often (always) this will be in production POV sections or articles. It is not necessary to reconcile the disagreement with speculation. Simply state the facts then note the discrepancy with a background note.
Black Dusty Power Blue T porter Freeman Strech x4qvAHYF

Summary:

Noting an occurrence that contradicts a well-established fact is not a nitpick, but carefully consider where it should be placed, and don't criticize.

Examples Edit

Not nitpicks Edit

  • Production decisions to change an established fact are noteworthy, especially if the note includes a reason (for example, the color of Klingon blood being changed to lavender in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country so the film would receive a PG rating.)
  • Established facts that are later contradicted by what may be a mistake are noteworthy (for example, Data's use of contractions, the number of decks on the USS Enterprise-E, the number of moons around Bajor).

Nitpicks Edit

  • Anything that starts with "Possibly the biggest goof in Star Trek..." or "Watch carefully..."
  • Observations that, although not contradictions per se, suggest something out-of-place; irrelevant observations:
    • A crewmember in a corridor appears to be chewing gum.
    • After Kirk confronts Dr. Jones in sickbay, watch Diana Muldaur trying to keep from laughing by biting her lip.
    • In this episode and "The Empath", Leonard Nimoy has some serious nasal congestion.
  • Comparisons or discrepancies between the Star Trek universe and the real world:
    • The existence of the USSR during the 23rd and 24th centuries.
  • The appearance of seemingly anachronistic items with no explanation:

See also Edit

Recent Wiki Activity

Help us grow Memory Alpha!
Get Started

  • Built with the same quality found in the legendary line of Irish Setter boots, the casual Traveler Chukka is perfect for evenings, weekends, or work
  • Full-grain leather upper with stylish stitching detail
  • Lace-up closure
  • Cushy memory foam footbed for enhanced comfort
  • Non-marking RPM sole provides exceptional comfort and durability

Heel Height 0
Material Leather
Brand Name Irish Setter
Color Tan

Shipping details for Irish Setter Traveler Chukka (Men's)

  • This item does not qualify for shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, or U.S. Territories.
  • This item does not qualify for shipping to Military APO/FPO addresses.
  • This item does not qualify for shipping to a P.O. Box. It must be shipped to a physical address.
  • This item does not qualify for shipping to AK,HI,PR,GU,VI,MP,FM,MH,PW,AS,AA,AE,AP